Impartial faculties can not ship efficient assist to state faculties in England with “a gun pointing at our heads”, a number one headmaster will say.
Mike Buchanan, of the Headmasters’ and Headmistresses’ Convention, will say “forcing” the sectors to work collectively is “fraught with difficulties”.
He’ll evaluate the federal government’s plan for altering the best way faculties work along with an organized marriage.
Ministers say many personal faculties have good state sector partnerships.
The Headmasters’ and Headmistresses’ Convention (HMC) represents 282 of the UK’s high impartial faculties.
‘Unlikely to work’
As a part of its proposals for secondary faculties in England, the federal government has stated impartial faculties will solely be capable to keep their charitable standing and tax breaks in the event that they arrange or sponsor an area state college.
Smaller personal faculties might be anticipated to ship academics to take classes in state faculties and the impartial sector should provide extra scholarships and bursaries to pupils who can not afford charges.
Talking on the HMC’s annual convention in Stratford-upon-Avon, Mr Buchanan will say: “Impartial and state faculties can not make work with a gun pointing at our heads.
“We hope the prime minister understands that – in spite of everything, she had the nice sense to outlaw pressured marriages as residence secretary.
“She should know, then, that each one good partnerships are based mostly on mutual want, understanding, respect and co-operation. They work finest when the events have a great deal in frequent.”
He’ll say that “sustainable partnerships” require “sensible issues”, akin to proximity, to work.
“The power to drop by, share experiences and speak by way of issues is a good asset as essentially the most profitable multi-academy trusts know,” he’ll say.
“Thus, within the messy, advanced actual world, forcing impartial and state faculties collectively is fraught with sensible difficulties and, in the end, is unlikely to work.”
Final month, Prime Minister Theresa Could outlined plans to extend the variety of “good” college locations.
She stated: “What we wish to do as a authorities is be sure that universities are taking extra of a task in supporting faculties and opening faculties, that there is extra of a contribution from the impartial sector, that we improve the variety of religion faculties and, sure, that we carry the ban on individuals organising or increasing selective faculties.”
Mr Buchanan, headmaster at Ashford Faculty in Kent, will pledge to help the federal government’s goals to enhance state sector schooling and provide extra locations in impartial faculties to those that can not afford full charges.
He’ll say: “We all know that our colleagues in state faculties typically do a implausible job with fewer sources, bigger lessons, extra curriculum constraints and considerably completely different challenges and we don’t presume to patronise them by suggesting we will essentially run their faculties higher than they’ll.
“However with open-hearted collaboration and a versatile method, nice issues can occur, and I’m hopeful the PM’s evidence-based and sensible method will prevail.”
A Division for Training (DfE) spokeswoman stated: “We recognise that many impartial faculties have already got profitable partnerships with state faculties and we welcome the pledge from the impartial college sector to proceed to assist to drive additional enhancements within the state schooling system.”
A 3-month session has opened on the DfE web site over the plans to create extra good college locations.
The spokeswoman stated: “We imagine impartial faculties may and will do extra in recognition of the tax advantages they obtain.
“That’s the reason we’re proposing that impartial faculties with the capability and functionality ought to sponsor academies or arrange a brand new free college, or provide a proportion of locations to much less rich youngsters.”