Sally Phillips and her son Olly

Ninety per cent of individuals within the UK who know their baby will likely be born with Down’s syndrome have an abortion – so there are issues a brand new, extremely correct check to establish infants with the situation, will result in much more terminations.

“The physician mentioned to us: ‘I am sorry, I am so sorry.’ The nurse on responsibility cried. I do not assume anybody mentioned something in any respect constructive,” says Sally Phillips. “It would not have been any completely different in the event that they’d informed me my baby wasn’t going to make it.”

Her son, Olly, was 10 days outdated, when he was examined for Down’s syndrome – the outcomes got here again constructive. However Phillips – the actress and screenwriter finest identified for her roles in Miranda and Bridget Jones – discovered life with a toddler with Down’s syndrome was not what the hushed tones and apologies had led her to count on

“I used to be informed it was a tragedy and truly it is a comedy. It is like a sitcom the place one thing seems to go incorrect however there’s nothing unhealthy on the finish of it.”

She describes life in her household as “simply barely funnier than in different households,” due to Olly, who’s now 12 and goes to a mainstream secondary college. She additionally has two youthful youngsters, neither of whom have Down’s.

“Having Olly in my life has modified me and my household for the higher. He has barely worse impulse management however that signifies that it is very humorous as a result of he is typically saying precisely what everyone’s considering however is just too shy to say.

“He is additionally extremely caring. He is the one one in every of my three children who each single day will ask me how my day was. He is actually form. He is actually centered on different folks. He is actually gifted emotionally. He’ll discover if persons are upset after I will not.”


Media captionMeet Sally and Olly

Sally Phillips explores the problems across the new prenatal check in A World Without Down’s Syndrome at 21:00 on Wednesday 5 October on BBC Two.


Within the UK, about 750 infants are born with Down’s syndrome yearly and there are an estimated 40,000 folks within the nation residing with the situation.

Most individuals have 23 pairs of chromosomes, however folks with Down’s have an additional copy of chromosome 21, which implies they develop in another way and have various ranges of studying incapacity. Some youngsters with Down’s have few well being issues, however sure medical problems – reminiscent of coronary heart, intestine, listening to, or thyroid situations – are extra widespread in folks with Down’s.

The current NHS screening, which is obtainable to all pregnant ladies, provides a sign of the chance child can have Down’s. If the foetus has the situation, there’s an 85% to 90% probability that the present check will choose it up, however about 2.5% of constructive outcomes are false and these infants haven’t got Down’s.

In the meanwhile, the subsequent step is amniocentesis or CVS (chorionic villus sampling), the one diagnostic assessments that may definitively present whether or not a child has Down’s syndrome. Each of those assessments are invasive – a needle is used to take a pattern of the fluid surrounding the infant or cells from the placenta – and include a threat of miscarriage. It is a threat some ladies usually are not keen to take.

Picture copyright
Science Picture Library

Picture caption

Amniocentesis is often guided by ultrasound

That is the place NIPT – the brand new non-invasive prenatal blood check – is available in. It may quickly be supplied to ladies as an additional, second step within the screening course of. It’s 99% correct and carries no threat of miscarriage.

So the false positives will likely be recognized earlier and fewer invasive assessments carried out.

That sounds good – however some folks, together with Sally Phillips, fear it can imply that extra foetuses with Down’s will likely be recognized and aborted.

NIPT is already out there in non-public clinics. One girl in her 20s who used it to search out out that her child had Down’s syndrome met up with Phillips to speak about her expertise.

After a constructive NIPT check she went forward with an invasive check which confirmed the end result.

It was her first being pregnant. Uncertain of what life for the kid can be like, she and her accomplice did some analysis on-line taking a look at information stories, movies of individuals with Down’s and assist group web sites.

“Slightly than the medical analysis and a physician saying, ‘That is what it can appear to be,’ what I used to be extra concerned with was household tales,” she says. They discovered a variety of constructive and inspirational testimonies, however some had been troubling.

“There have been blogs by mums so that you see among the difficulties that persons are going by. There was one girl, her five-year-old’s nonetheless not strolling and he is very heavy and she or he’s having to take care of him having matches in every single place,” she says.

“If my baby was affected as a lot as he was I’d really feel actually responsible about that having been given the selection. Even the perfect case situation is not what I would like for my son.”

So she and her accomplice determined to finish the being pregnant. “We felt that was the perfect factor for the infant,” she says.

For Phillips it may be troublesome to simply accept that somebody does not desire a baby like hers.

And she or he is fearful that her son will develop up in a world the place extra mother and father select to not give delivery to infants recognized with the situation. She provides the instance of Iceland, the place nearly everybody screens for Down’s and 100% of girls who’ve a constructive prognosis now terminate.

Icelandic photographer Sigga Ella, whose aunt had the situation, took a series of portraits of individuals with Down’s to lift consciousness of the Down’s neighborhood there.

Picture copyright
Sigga Ella

Picture caption

Jakob

Picture copyright
Sigga Ella

Picture caption

Halldora

Picture copyright
Sigga Ella

Picture caption

Birta

However within the UK a few third of pregnant ladies choose out of screening, so if that is still the case, any of those infants who’ve Down’s will proceed to go undetected till they’re born.

Within the UK the brand new check is being developed by Lyn Chitty at Nice Ormond Avenue Hospital – professor of genetics and foetal medication.

She carried out a examine to see what ladies do when they’re supplied NIPT. Based mostly on this analysis she believes that an additional 195 infants with Down’s could possibly be recognized in England and Wales every year earlier than delivery.

However though 90% of girls within the UK with a constructive Down’s prognosis have abortions, she does not consider it means most of those 195 pregnancies will likely be terminated.

“I actually don’t assume that we’re going to be screening out Down’s syndrome,” she says. “I discover it fairly distressing. I had a journalist telephone me up and say ‘You are going to annihilate Down’s.’ Nicely, I do not assume that is going to occur.

“The difficulty is everyone’s taking a look at hypothetical eventualities, they’re taking a look at ‘what if’ conditions.

“We discovered that a variety of ladies had been utilizing the NIPT check to search out out whether or not their child’s obtained Down’s syndrome, inform themselves and keep on with the being pregnant. If you look at our statistics it won’t considerably change the stay delivery charge.”

The statistics referring to terminations are complicated and interpreted in another way by both sides of the talk. However all consultants agree that the best way a prognosis of Down’s syndrome is offered can affect whether or not mother and father select to proceed with the being pregnant.

Picture copyright
iStock

“The entire essence of a superb screening programme is the counselling you will have earlier than you even have the blood check finished or the scan finished,” says Alan Cameron, foetal medication advisor at Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Glasgow.

“You have to be given an informed selection, however definitely my expertise is that a lot fewer ladies would terminate now than they ever did earlier than as a result of I believe issues are higher… folks see Down’s children having good, wholesome, lives, working in the neighborhood, you see children round with Down’s syndrome which can be doing a superb job.”

Within the early 1980s life expectancy for a kid born with Down’s was 25 years, however right this moment it is about 60, with some residing into their 70s. And a report published in 2014 exhibits how employers can profit from hiring employees with Down’s.

Screening has by no means been a case of “let’s try to eradicate Down’s syndrome from the inhabitants,” says Cameron. “That is by no means been the mission… It was all on the again of girls’s selection.”

He admits, although, that whereas medics have lengthy thought-about the ethics and penalties of screening amongst themselves, they have not been superb at discussing this with their sufferers and the general public.

That is the place the Nuffield Council on Bioethics is available in. Whereas the federal government will get able to announce the roll-out of NIPT throughout the NHS, the council has been chatting with scientists, docs, coverage makers, folks with Down’s and their households to evaluate what influence it may have.

“There was screening for Down’s Syndrome for many years, so by way of the enterprise of providing ladies knowledgeable selection NIPT does not actually change that,” says Tom Shakespeare, chairman of the Nuffield working group, which plans to publish its report in February.

Nevertheless it does open the door to testing for different situations.

“It could possibly be utilized by individuals who have a single gene situation, like cystic fibrosis or muscular dystrophy or achondroplasia – my very own situation,” he says.

“In the end you can have entire genome sequencing so you can check that pattern for the whole lot – it is the subsequent step and since NIPT is non-invasive you are not going to threat the foetus.”

And for him, like Sally Phillips, it comes again to how outcomes and knowledge are given to potential mother and father.

“I assist the choice of screening for those who need it but it surely must be on the premise of excellent high quality info – why are potential mother and father not being given the total details about Down’s syndrome?”

“It is not nearly trisomy 21 (Down’s syndrome) or threat of mental incapacity – it is also about what are folks’s lives like? What limitations do they face? Do they endure? In the event you’re probably having a child with a situation, that is what you need to know – how will it have an effect on my household? How will it have an effect on my baby? How will it have an effect on their life? How a lot of an issue is it?”

These are questions the brand new blood check is just not in a position to reply.


Karen Gaffney is a 38 year-old American girl with Down’s syndrome. Final yr she gave a TED discuss on why her life issues. That is an edited model of her speech – you may watch the full version here.

Picture copyright
Barbara Gaffney

I want to begin by telling you about my fifth grade instructor. It was her first yr of instructing after I confirmed up in her class. She did not know something about Down syndrome however that did not matter, as a result of she knew I wished to study, and she or he wished to show. She and I’ve stayed in contact. A couple of years in the past, I obtained a particular letter from her – she informed me that she was pregnant and she or he wanted my assist, as a result of her child can be born with Down’s syndrome!

She pushed again on any dialogue of termination as a result of she knew Down syndrome from a very completely different perspective than her physician did. She taught him about her fifth grade pupil… me!

There was a time when folks like me had been institutionalised. After I was born, the physician predicted that I’d be fortunate to have the ability to tie my very own sneakers or write my very own identify – he forgot to say the half about me swimming the English Channel.

Now we have begun to see increasingly more younger folks with Down’s syndrome graduating from excessive faculties, some happening to greater schooling and studying employable expertise. There are completed musicians, artists, golfers, fashions, actors and public audio system, in addition to good staff making important contributions to their corporations and communities. These are all function fashions for what could be finished regardless of one additional chromosome.

It is from good, although, breakthroughs have not come for everybody and we nonetheless have battles to struggle for inclusion.

And it appears the race is on to search out newer, sooner methods to check for that additional chromosome earlier than delivery – the issue is with out well timed and correct info, about all our progress, if the check exhibits an additional chromosome, pregnancies are being terminated. Now we have those that say we should not even be born in any respect.

I consider Down’s syndrome is a life price saying sure to. Each life issues whatever the variety of chromosomes now we have.

Picture copyright
Barbara Gaffney

Picture caption

Karen Gaffney earlier than a 9-mile swim throughout Lake Tahoe


Be part of the dialog – discover us on Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat and Twitter.